Page 1 of 1

Investment Rollup/ taxes

Posted: Sun Jun 05, 2016 7:51 am
by gg80108
I put my IRA into Tax Def Portfolio and put in an additional input of a 3% rate of return. Starting age 64, taking nothing till RMDs. I don't see the Tax deferred portfolio increasing by 3% before RMDs. Min withdrawal age 70.

I get social security and use cash to live on. I put my cash into Tax Free Portfolio(?). I selected Withdrawals from taxable, then tax-free, . I can see the tax free going down, tax deferred steady, but there is a large amount of taxes, where there should be zero taxes till RMD time. I even put 0 tax rates in where ever I could find but still takes out taxes. At age 70 the taxes go to zero.
Looks like the program has a 10% tax built in for Tax Free withdrawls..

Does this program figure out how much of your social security is taxable if any?

Re: Investment Rollup/ taxes

Posted: Sun Jun 05, 2016 7:57 am
by jimr
All of the planner outputs are shown in today's value dollars.

That means if the def portfolio rate of return is 3% and inflation is 3%, the year-to-year portfolio balance would be expected to stay exactly flat, indicating that it's exactly keeping up with inflation, no more and no less.

Re: Investment Rollup/ taxes

Posted: Sun Jun 05, 2016 8:01 am
by jimr
On the taxes, by chance did you change the min IRA/401k withdrawal age? That setting determines the minimum age you can take penalty free withdrawals from deferred and tax free accounts. Perhaps what you're seeing in taxes is from a penalty?